I became the victim of my own success. A paper built around a full-scale attack on the source material or even the assumptions of the essay question.
On a recent assignment, for example, I had one very good paper that took a general prompt about development policies in colonial Africa and zoomed in very tightly on agriculture and gender.
Every once in a while, I get an undergraduate who has some justifiable reason to assert this sort of authority, but most of the time, it is a mistake, though often an unconscious one.
Words and phrases that implicitly or explicitly assert mastery of the entire corpus of material related to the assignment, often through language that compares a source text to all other source texts of the class X from which the text comes. As a young, new teacher, I welcomed the structure—yes, the rigidness—that the 5-paragraph essay offered.
I often suggest some pre-built analytic structures that go beyond the usual five-paragraph essay that students are taught to write in K schooling.
And my students were frustrated, too. It asks students to determine how many paragraphs they need instead of how many paragraphs a teacher requires.
An essay built around a very tight interpretation of a single word, phrase, metaphor or other linguistic component of a source or scholarly account, or focus on a tight comparison of several related passages.
There were many conflicts over these rules. Every once in a while, I get an undergraduate who has some justifiable reason to assert this sort of authority, but most of the time, it is a mistake, though often an unconscious one.
And they have little chance to fall in love with writing, to feel how fun it can be, and to see how writing can help them solve problems and figure things out. All anonymous, of course, and following my Paula-like nature, nothing especially brutal in terms of the actual grades dispensed.
Foster genre awareness in students while interrogating authentic texts and rejecting artificial writing templates. Skip to content Beyond the Five-Paragraph Essay When I hand back analytic essays, I try to leave room to do a collective post-mortem and talk about common problems or challenges that appeared in a number of essays.
The composite effect is like reading a telegraph message. The essay can be written around a block comparison, where the two or more things to be compared are discussed separately in longer multi-paragraph sections, or on a point-by-point basis, alternating each paragraph.
I wonder if we have a fake-writing problem, too. Yes, it does have structure. This is not the 18th Century. Or if not the Aristotelian approach, then why not the Rogerian method? Sometimes there are unique problems that arise in relation to a particular essay question, which is sometimes a consequence of my having given enough rope for certain students to hang themselves in the phrasing of the question.
This data is anonymized, and will not be used for marketing purposes.
Even in literature-based courses like AP Lit which I have also taughtstudents need skills in writing literary analysis, not 5-paragraph essays. But as Bomer points out: Be forgiving of yourself, too. Their writing was messy.
In fact, one of my students said that she could see how this structure would have been helpful in writing her social studies paper. Instead of limiting students to fake-writing assignments, one that may be easier to tame i.
This is also very simple, and often produces a mediocre paper that is purely descriptive and non-analytical, but if it is done well, can be very sophisticated.
Colonial authorities controlled customary rules and rulers. Sometimes I see an argument in the first paragraph or in the last paragraph the latter often appearing to be a last-minute discovery that is cut off from the rest of the essay, unexplored or unsupported. A structure that is more precisely fitted to historical writing, where it traces the development of a theme or issue over time.
But this process is precisely the opposite of what should happen. And they have a point. March 22, Beyond the Five-Paragraph Essay When I hand back analytic essays, I try to leave room to do a collective post-mortem and talk about common problems or challenges that appeared in a number of essays.
Sometimes I see an argument in the first paragraph or in the last paragraph the latter often appearing to be a last-minute discovery that is cut off from the rest of the essay, unexplored or unsupported.
We forget the loves and the betrayals alike, forget what we whispered and what we screamed, forget who we were.Beyond High School Writing: Rethinking the 5-Paragraph Essay • What is the 5 -paragraph essay?
o Introduction paragraph o 3 body paragraphs. Beyond the Five Paragraph Essay by Kimberly Hill Campbell and Kristi Latimer is a book for all teachers who feel, as the authors do, that the five-paragraph essay format encourages students “to say very little in a very organized way.” It is a book written with respect for young writers, who.
The Writing Resource Center’s Campus Workshop Series kicks off next week with a workshop titled “Beyond the 5-Paragraph Essay.” The workshop will take place on Friday, Sept. 30, from to p.m. in Bellflower Hall, Room Using the standard five-paragraph essay as a familiar point of departure, this workshop will help students develop strategies that reflect a more nuanced and.
Introducing the College Essay Model: Beyond the 5-Paragraph Essay. So What’s Wrong with the High-School Model?: The 5-Paragraph Model Introduction: states what the essay will be about Three-Pronged Thesis: points 1, 2, and 3 are listed in order of appearance.
March 22, Beyond the Five-Paragraph Essay. When I hand back analytic essays, I try to leave room to do a collective post-mortem and talk about common problems or challenges that appeared in a number of essays.
Beyond the Five-Paragraph Essay. Love it or hate it, the five-paragraph essay is perhaps the most frequently taught form of writing in classrooms of yesterday and today.Download